Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Fannie Mae (update)

In yesterday's post, I asserted that Fannie Mae lacks the authority to exempt itself from state disclosure laws. After doing additional research, I now conclude . . . that I was right.

A federal district court judge in Pennsylvania recently ruled that Fannie Mae is exempt from state and county transfer taxes.  The judge's opinion can be read here.  That makes four out of five federal decisions that have gone Fannie's way on that issue.  The judge based his ruling on a federal statute, 12 U.S.C. § 1723a(c)(2), which specifically exempts Fannie from transfer taxes.

But there is no similar statute granting to Fannie an exemption from disclosure laws.  It would be surprising to have Congress act to enable Fannie to drop hidden time bombs on unsuspecting buyers, after all.  Fannie is not exempt from disclosure requirements under state law, whether those requirements be for hidden defects, presence of lead paint, underground septic tanks, or anything else.  Furthermore, there is no prohibition in the Fannie Mae charter against issuing disclosure statements as some lenders have asserted in the past.

Therefore, Fannie Mae is being misleading, at best, when it includes this language in the addendum that it demands be signed by every purchaser of an REO property:
6) BUYER acknowledges that they [sic] understand Seller has never occupied, seen or personally inspected the property, and is exempt from traditional property condition disclosures.  ______ buyer initials. 
Fannie Mae might take the position that this claim is self-executing, meaning that regardless of whether there is a statutory basis for an exemption, Fannie Mae becomes exempt once a purchaser signs the addendum acknowledging the existence of the exemption.  I believe this argument too would fail.  No one, not even a quasi-government entity, can contract away its obligation to obey the law.

 

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Fannie Mae's Undisclosed Problems

In a previous post, I described my own encounter with the heavy-handed and self-defeating procedures utilized by Fannie Mae to unload its REO/foreclosed properties.  I quoted the following provision from the contract addendum that Fannie Mae asks all purchasers to sign:
6) BUYER acknowledges that they [sic] understand Seller has never occupied, seen or personally inspected the property, and is exempt from traditional property condition disclosures.  ______ buyer initials.
I made the following comment:
I don't think it is quite that easy, however.  State disclosure laws still obligate the owner to disclose what he knows, even if he never lived at the property.  It is possible that Fannie Mae could receive an inspection report from a potential buyer, which would then need to be disclosed to future buyers.  I've read elsewhere that Fannie Mae attempts to avoid this problem by remaining willfully blind.  They refuse to accept any inspection reports because they do not want to be obligated to disclose anything.
This week, I had another encounter with Fannie Mae that might demonstrates the willful blindness I mentioned.

I had an interest in this house, which recently appeared on the County Sheriff's sale list:
1337 SE Cherokee
A review of the court records revealed that Bank of America (successor to Countrywide Home Loans Servicing, LP) filed the foreclosure action in September of 2011, alleging an indebtedness in the amount of $112,194 on a loan of $125,800.  (The house has been vacant since that time.)  Judgment was obtained in December of 2011, the property was appraised at $130,000, and it was sold at sheriff's sale.  Then the plaintiff's attorneys realized that they goofed by not attaching the endorsed note to the Petition, so they asked that their own judgment be vacated so that they could start over.

A new judgment was entered in August of 2012, but the plaintiff's attorneys bungled that one as well, so they once again had to start over.

A third execution and order of sale issued in December of 2012, and a sale was scheduled for February 19, 2013.  This time, the house was appraised at $146,000.  There is no explanation for why the appraised value went up by $16,000 in two years.  During that time, it suffered water damage, was broken into, and, based upon the items I saw on the floor when I peeked through the window, might have been used as a meth cook site.  I doubt that the meth chef made $16,000 in improvements to the interior.  

I was interested in bidding on the property, so in an attempt to gather all of the information I could, I tracked the mortgagor down and mailed her a letter, asking her to disclose what she knew about the physical condition of the property.  I was overwhelmed by her emailed response:

I had put in a koi pond in the back which was apparently vandalized a couple of months after we left.  I don't know if vandals ever broke into the inside of the house.

The roof on the back of the house (south corner) was damaged after a nasty windstorm.  The fascia board was almost completely torn off because the power to house was (brilliantly) attached to that instead of a more sturdy structure.  This exposed an opening that I imagine now may have a few critters seeking refuge... not to mention weather having access.

The kitchen has new appliances... Stainless steel side by side, oven with glass top and dishwasher.  The dishwasher apparently had a leak and may have damaged the floor beneath the vinyl tiles.

NONE of the windows downstairs will open (bought it that way).. Never got to fixing them because of the $10,000 quote.  The basement will be your biggest issue.

When there is a moderate rain, or snow melt, the basement floods.  There is a working sump pump, but (again brilliantly) it was attached to a garden hose outside... so when the temperature freezes... so does the hose... the sump pump will turn on, but not be able to evacuate any of the water due to ice in the hose.  There is a sink above the pump that goes to a regular drain, so you would have to bail out the pump into the sink.

When you have moderate to heavy rain or snow melt, water comes up through cracks in the floor, and squirts out of the walls like a water fountain.  My guess is the only way to solve the water issue in the basement is via French drains, but again... I couldn't afford to have them installed.

There are two HVAC units... one for upstairs one for downstairs.  I replaced the upstairs one a couple of years after I moved in.  The downstairs one died just before I left.  It was old... very old.

The wiring in the house is tricky.  Since I had a home based business, I had one room in the house completely re-wired to protect my computers, faxes, printers, copiers, etc.  The bedroom next to the downstairs bath is what I refer to as the 'safe room'.  It's the only one with decent electrical.

When in the basement, if you look up you will see the ceramic tubes with wire wrapped around them (old school wiring).  Whether that's active or not, or runs through the rest of the house or not, I can't really say.  There is a panel downstairs that the electrician worked with, and he didn't seem overly concerned.

I ran power out the garage because I had a lot of wood working equipment and had several outlets placed throughout the garage to accommodate them.

I also had power run from the garage out to where the pond is/was. It has it's own breaker in the garage.

The front facing window in the office/bedroom has a storm window.  The month that I left the house there was a huge storm.  The window filled with water then poured into the office.  I ended up drilling holes in the sill to help drain the water to the outside of the house because I couldn't get the storm window off.  It helped a lot, but the window would still leak into the room during a heavy storm.

In short, the house has everything but a poltergeist.  This was useful information.  I substantially adjusted my own  valuation of the property downward, but was still determined to attend the sale.

At the sale, the bank's attorney made a bid of approximately $99,000, which was more than I wanted to pay for a house that has alternating founts of storm water and bolts of electricity shooting out of the walls, so the bank got it, at which point it handed it off to Fannie Mae and exited the stage.

Eleven days ago, a For Sale sign appeared in the yard.  As with the other house I blogged about, Re/Max is the listing copany, but all offers must be made on-line, using Fannie Mae's Homepath website.  Here's the Homepath page for this particular property, offering it for sale at $121,900.  

If you view the photos and read through all the information on the webpage, you will not find any indication of the problems detailed in the email I received from the previous owner.  That's not surprising, since Fannie Mae never "lived there," and had no reason to seek out the previous owner for information.  

This is where the addendum language comes in.  It states that Fannie Mae has not seen the property and is exempt from disclosure laws.  Isn't it odd that they feel the need to announce that they are exempt?  If they have not seen the property and can honestly say they are not aware of any problems, why isn't that enough?  No "exemption" is necessary.

Maybe it is because there have been reports of Fannie Mae being informed of problems, whereupon they become deaf and dumb.  Consider this first-person account of Fannie Mae disclosure practices in California:
I used to work with a small team of REO listing agents and we had a Fannie Mae account. The asset managers expressly forbid us from sending them any reports or inspections on the properties. Even worse, they expressly forbid us from accepting or even looking at any inspections or reports done by buyers during an escrow. Their advice to us was that if a buyer’s agent emailed over an inspection report, delete it. 
Yes, the asset managers actually told us to delete files.
But such a thing wouldn't happen in Oklahoma, would it?  I emailed Re/MAX the list of horrors reproduced above, explaining that I received the list from the previous owner.  I asked whether any of those problems had been corrected.  Here is the reply I received:
Thank you for your interest in the property. The only repairs that are being done to our knowledge are some electrical and the only appliance that remains in home is a dishwasher. 
Okay, so they have chosen not to fix the leaky basement and other problems.  That's fine, but now that they are on notice of the problems, they must disclose them to all potential buyers.  60 O.S. 833 reads as follows:
A. A seller of property located in this state shall deliver, or cause to be delivered, to the purchaser of such property one of the following:
1. A written property disclaimer statement on a form established by rule by the Oklahoma Real Estate Commission which states that the seller:
a. has never occupied the property and makes no disclosures concerning the condition of the property, and
b. has no actual knowledge of any defect.
The Realtor also has a disclosure obligation per 60 O.S. 836(C):
A real estate licensee has the duty to disclose to the purchaser any defects in the property actually known to the licensee which are not included in the disclosure statement or any amendment.
Will Fannie Mae meet their disclosure obligations, or will they rely upon their self-proclaimed "exemption"?  If you are interested in 1337 SE Cherokee, I urge you to ask about known problems.  Let me know what you are told.  



Monday, August 12, 2013

The Bee Counters

Where in the Constitution is the general government delegated the authority to count bees and produce manuals teaching others how to capture bees and start their own collection?  I don't know, but these photos are cool.

My guess is that Thomas Jefferson would oppose this sort of governmental activity, but with great reluctance.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

"Patience is required . . . "




About this time last year, Fannie Mae started bragging about all the money they were making.  One might wonder why the U. S. government acted to bail out Fannie Mae in 2008, disbursing over $116 billion in taxpayer dollars.  I recently got a clue from my own Fannie Mae encounter.

A house that is across the street and two doors down from my own had been vacant for some time, so I did some poking around and learned that it was in foreclosure.  CitiCorp started the foreclosure proceeding in February of 2011, with the filing of a petition.  Attached to the petition is a copy of the note, showing that $84,000 was borrowed against this house.  THAT IS CRAZY.  We are talking about a simple 2-bedroom house that doesn't even have central heat and air.

The property owners were successfully served with summonses and failed to answer, so CitiCorp was able to get a quick default judgment.  Still, it wasn't until January of the following year that the property went to sheriff's sale.  It was then appraised at $55,800 (the same property that served as collateral for a loan of $84,000).  CitiCorp was the high bidder at the auction, acquiring the property for $37,200.

Oh, but there was a problem.  CitiCorp discovered that CitiMortgage, its own sister company, held a superior mortgage lien against the property in the amount of $38,500.  Oops!  The sheriff's sale had to be vacated and the foreclosure was dismissed.  (Did you pause and notice that a house with an appraised value of $55,800 was serving as collateral for loans totaling in excess of $122,000?  CitiCorp did not pause.)

In October of 2012, a new foreclosure action was filed, this time by CitiMortgage.  It named CitiBank, successor to CitiCorp, as a defendant.  Essentially, CitiMortgage sued itself.  Again, a default judgment was obtained and the property went to sheriff's sale.  This time, it was appraised at $45,800.  There is no apparent explanation for the $10,000 drop in appraised value.  (Don't these dumb appraisers know that this is a $122,000 house, according to the lenders?!!) Still, this is high, based upon my own knowledge of my neighborhood and Bartlesville real estate prices.

I attended the sheriff's sale, hopeful that I could acquire the property and use it as a rental.  Bidding against the attorney for CitiMortgage, I bid as high as $39,000, but the bank's attorney kept going, acquiring the property for $40,000.

The sale was confirmed on May 13, 2013, more than two years after the initial foreclosure filing, at which point the bank orally assigned the property to Fannie Mae.  The sheriff's deed was then issued to Fannie Mae.  You see, both of those undercollaterized loans were held by Fannie Mae, with CitiCorp/CitiMortgage merely acting as proxy/servicer of the loans.

Last week, Fannie Mae listed the property for sale through Re/MAX with an asking price of $25,500.  



This is where another pause is warranted, maybe even some head scratching.  Is this not the same property that was just appraised at $45,800?  Is it the same property that served as collateral for $122,000 in loans?  More importantly, isn't it the same property that I tried to buy for $39,000?  Yes, it is.  So why would a bank forego an offer of $39,000, only to turn around and list the same property for sale through a Realtor (who will receive a commission) at $25,500?

The short answer is that a bank would not do that.  But here, Fannie Mae is in the equation.  My guess is that the bank is made whole by Fannie Mae, regardless of how much it brings at sheriff's sale, so the bank does not care.  It might as well bid up the price all the way to the judgment amount, then kick it over to Fannie Mae.  The loss is then the problem of Fannie Mae and Fannie Mae's shareholders, or it would be if not for the federal bailout.  

I saw this same scenario play out once before, but involving much bigger dollars.  It made such an impression on me that I created a simple one-page website that tells the story.  You can find it here.  Apparently, little has changed.

Okay, whatever . . . maybe the taxpayers' loss can be my gain.  I decided to submit an offer on the house.  Per Fannie Mae's rules, only an owner-occupant may submit offers during the first 15 days of the listing of a REO property.  After that, "investors" are free to make offers.  Yesterday was the first day that investors could submit offers, so my own Realtor punched in the data to submit my offer online.  (Fannie Mae requires that all offers by submitted online, using their dedicated website.)  

But then Fannie Mae's Realtor informed us that Fannie Mae has come up with a new requirement. All potential buyers must sign and initial a 4-page "disclosure" that overrides much of the standard language found in any purchase and sale contract.  The provisions of this disclosure are so absurd, that I have to quote them.
1) REALTORS AND BUYERS: unlike traditional transactions, an REO/Foreclosure Seller [that's Fannie Mae] may CANCEL the CONTRACT at any time, for any reason.  _______ buyer initials.
Should I ask that I as the buyer also be given the ability to cancel for any reason at any time?  My guess is that they will tell me that some "traditions" are worth keeping and some are not.
3) . . . Patience is required to purchase an REO/Foreclosed property.  ______ buyer initials.
Are they asking me to stipulate that I have patience, or that I understand that I will need patience?  Should I also be patient in expecting Fannie Mae to pay back all of those bailout funds that they received?
4) REALTORS: Please make Buyer aware that after they [sic] have reached an agreement with the REO Seller, there will be additional addenda that will need to be signed.  In some cases this addenda will not be available for several days after the agreement is reached.  Patience is required, this [sic] is the normal process for REO companies.  _____ buyer initials.
I really don't know what this means, but it reads as though I must promise to agree to future changes to the agreement.  Those future changes are not known, but I need to be patient.
6) BUYER acknowledges that they [sic] understand Seller has never occupied, seen or personally inspected the property, and is exempt from traditional property condition disclosures.  ______ buyer initials.
Darn it, there went another one of those "traditions."  I don't think it is quite that easy, however.  State disclosure laws still obligate the owner to disclose what he knows, even if he never lived at the property.  It is possible that Fannie Mae could receive an inspection report from a potential buyer, which would then need to be disclosed to future buyers.  I've read elsewhere that Fannie Mae attempts to avoid this problem by remaining willfully blind.  They refuse to accept any inspection reports because they do not want to be obligated to disclose anything.
12) BUYER agrees to pay a $50.00 - or other amount required by Seller - per diem, in the event Seller agrees to Buyer's written request for a contract extension.  This per diem will be charged for each day through and including the new closing date specified in the written extension. ____ buyer initials.
Oh, but what if it is Fannie May who wants to extend the closing date?  Well, then patience is required.
13) SELLER (FANNIE MAE) REQUIRES THAT LOCKS BE CHANGED BY LOCKSMITH PRIOR TO CLOSING, AND THE CHARGE FOR THE RE-KEY MUST APPEAR ON THE CLOSING HUD STATEMENT.  BUYER IS REQUIRED TO PAY FOR FOR THIS RE-KEY CHARGE.  _______ buyer initials.
This one is handwritten in block letters.  If this disclosure statement really must be signed in every REO foreclosure sale, I would suggest that Fannie Mae go all out and type the whole thing.
14) . . . It will be at the sole discretion of the Seller to turn on utilities for Inspections, on a case by case basis.
Maybe my case would be one of the lucky ones!
15) BUYER should also be aware that certain deed restrictions will be placed on the property to prevent the re-sale of that property within a short period of time, usually 60 to 90 days, this [sic] is determined by the Seller.  This practice by the Seller is to prevent flipping.  This applies to owner-occupants as well as investors.  ______ buyer initials.
I would call this the envy clause.  Fannie Mae invites investors to make offers, so Fannie Mae wants them to invest, but just not make a profit.  Profits are wicked.  So sign now, Mr. Investor, and you'll be informed later of precisely how long you must sit on your investment.  It will be "determined by the Seller."
. . . BUYERS and REALTORS: Please note: [sic] most foreclosure companies use title companies in Tulsa or Oklahoma City.  If you desire to close in Bartlesville, there will be a courtesy closing fee, which is approximately $225.00. 
Maybe you'll be driving an hour to the closing, or maybe two and a half hours.  If you don't like guessing, then cough up some "courtesy."

The final provision, also handwritten, gives notice that the Buyer will be responsible for paying the title report fee and the abstracting fee.  "Traditionally a seller's cost."

They might as well add a provision that says, "Don't even think about buying one of our properties, or we'll make you sorry."

Is there any wonder why Fannie Mae is so slow to move its inventory?  Fannie Mae is a collector -- it collects foreclosed properties, and it collects taxpayer dollars.




Tuesday, July 23, 2013

The Other Shoe Dropped in Ohio

It didn't take long.  In U.S. v. Windsor, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down that portion of the Defense of Marriage Act that defines marriage for federal purposes.  Justice Kennedy, writing for the majority, strained to reassure readers of the opinion that the applicability of the ruling was limited to the federal government and had no impact upon the ability of the States to define marriage.

Chief Justice Roberts, in his dissenting opinion, wrote:
While I disagree with the result …I think it more important to point out that its analysis leads no further. . . The Court does not have before it, and the logic of its opinion does not decide, the distinct question whether the States…may continue to utilize the traditional definition of marriage.
 Justice Scalia was not so gullible.  In his dissent, he wrote:
In my opinion . . . the view that this Court will take of state prohibition of same-sex marriage is indicated beyond mistaking by today’s opinion . . . As far as this Court is concerned, no one should be fooled; it is just a matter of listening and waiting for the other shoe.
 Addressing Justice Kennedy, Scalia wrote:
It takes real cheek for today’s majority to assure us, as it is going out the door, that a constitutional requirement to give formal recognition to same-sex marriage is not at issue here—when what has preceded that assurance is a lecture on how superior the majority’s moral judgment in favor of same-sex marriage is to the Congress’s hateful moral judgment against it.
In other words, Prophet Scalia was predicting that the Windsor decision would soon be used as a precedent to declare a STATE's definition of marriage unconstitutional.  I thought it would take longer than a month for Scalia to be proven correct, but this week it was reported that a federal judge in Ohio ordered state officials to recognize the marriage of two men that was performed in Maryland.  Citing language from Windsor, the judge declared Ohio's definition of marriage as being between a man and a woman to be a violation of the U. S. Constitution.


Thursday, May 23, 2013

A Conspiracy to Commit Journalism

Over the past two weeks, we've learned that the Justice Department has tapped the phones of AP and Fox News reporters as part of two separate leak investigations.  This revelation has provoked much angry buzzing from members of the press and talking heads who typically give obeisance to the Obama administration and keep their stingers pointed elsewhere.

Much of the loudest buzzing has centered around the news that the Justice Department labeled Fox News reporter James Rosen a conspirator for soliciting information from a State Department contractor for a story.  It caught my attention that ABC's Jack Tapper, in commenting on the Justice Department's treatment of Rosen, remarked that this is sarcastically being referred to as "a conspiracy to commit journalism."

I also found an opinion piece by Xeni Jardin using that phrase as the caption.

I then remembered where I first heard this phrase.  In was in a 2001 column by Ann Coulter, in which she discussed the Senate Democrats' attempt to torpedo the nomination of Ted Olson for Solicitor General.  The torpedo was Olson's association with The American Spectator ("TAS") and its "Arkansas Project."


I should back up.  In 1994, TAS pushed over the first domino that would ultimately lead to the impeachment of President Bill Clinton with the publication of "His Cheatin' Heart," an article by David Brock about Gov. Clinton's use of Arkansas State Troopers to help facilitate his multiple trysts.  (I think I first subscribed to TAS in '92, and I remember the article well.)

This was followed by several more investigative stories aimed at the Clintons.  Funding for these stories came, in part, from the Scaife Foundation.  This newly enhanced investigative function of TAS came to be known as the Arkansas Project.  Some of what the Arkansas Project uncovered became part of the Kenneth Starr investigation, and at least one of Starr's witnesses, Judge Hale from Arkansas, was also a source for some of the TAS pieces.

The Clinton forces, bloodied and bruised but not out, managed to get a special counsel of their own appointed to investigate the Arkansas Project.  The primary allegation was that of witness tampering, but in the end, TAS itself was being investigated.  There were no indictments, and the special counsel concluded that no crimes had been committed.  But the investigation just about ended TAS.  I remember that the publication was taken over by George Gilder, who acted as sort of a caretaker, at the time.  All but two members of the staff were fired or left.

Returning to the nomination of Ted Olson, the Arkansas Project was used against him on the basis of Olson having served on the board of the American Spectator Foundation during the time of the Arkansas Project.  In criticizing this attack on Olson, Ann Coulter, began her column with the following:
Last week, every Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee voted against Ted Olson, Bush's nominee for solicitor general. The Democrats are troubled by accusations that Olson may have associated with conservatives who were conspiring to commit journalism.
I have no idea whether Ann Coulter was the first to use that phrase, but that's the first place I saw it.  In 2007, Ted Olson was nominated to be Attorney General and the Arkansas Project once again came up.  Interestingly, the Wall Street Journal then published the following in its editorial:
Ultimately the Spectator board voted to shut down the project, and in any case committing journalism is not a crime. The Arkansas Project was never accused of breaking any laws, although the Clinton Justice Department did investigate the magazine over the campaign, which strikes us as a much creepier sort of partisanship than exercising one's First Amendment rights.
Referring to it as a "creepier sort of partisanship" is somewhat of an understatement.  In essence, the president used the power of the Justice Department to go after his enemies and attempt to silence, if not jail, the reporters and publishers doing him harm.  At the time, I thought it betrayed ideological blindness and shortsightedness on the part of the mainstream press when it looked the other way and pretended not to notice.  Now that the current Justice Department is tapping the phones of the AP, they are taking notice.

"Conspiracy to commit journalism" is a clever phrase, but unfortunately, this is not the first time such sarcasm is warranted.

Friday, May 17, 2013

The 30-Year War


Yesterday, the Senate Armed Services Committee held a hearing on the 2001 Authorization to Use Military Force (AUMF).  Due to this week's scandal trifecta, the hearing received little coverage, so you might have missed the revelation that our two War Parties have delivered the United States' first 30-year war.  Wired's Spencer Ackerman described the relevant exchange here:
"Asked at a Senate hearing today how long the war on terrorism will last, Michael Sheehan, the assistant secretary of defense for special operations and low-intensity conflict, answered, 'At least 10 to 20 years.' . . . A spokeswoman, Army Col. Anne Edgecomb, clarified that Sheehan meant the conflict is likely to last 10 to 20 more years from today - atop the 12 years that the conflict has already lasted. Welcome to America's Thirty Years War."
You'll recall that the AUMF was passed in response to the 9/11 attack.  Although it did not contain the word "war," it came to serve as the legal basis for engaging in a global war on terror that has no termination point and no geographic boundary.  But despite the war fatigue of the U.S. electorate, there is no talk of repealing the AUMF, rather the committee only considered whether it needs to be broadened.  Does anyone know what victory will look like?